Top searches

PL

Resources

How to limit your potential liability to the tax authorities. A closer look at the anti-avoidance clause.

07/08/2020

Everyone must comply with their responsibilities and public duties, including the payment of taxes, as specified by Article 84 of the Constitution. Poland has relatively strong measures to enforce compliance with tax obligations, and an example of this is the so-called anti-avoidance clause. This considers whether a legal or factual act was carried out in order to obtain a tax advantage and determines the amount of tax liability in accordance with the real nature of an act and not in accordance with what the taxpayer declared or demonstrated, regardless of other consequences, such as the possibility of initiating penal and fiscal proceedings.

However, the legal possibilities of the State are not unlimited and it is worth noting an existing limitation stemming from the statute, according to which, the anti-avoidance clause does not, in principle, apply to an entity which has obtained a protective tax ruling, to the extent covered by the ruling, until the effective date of the revocation or amendment of a protective ruling. It should be noted that there is a difference between a protective tax ruling and an individual tax interpretation because, in the case of individual interpretations, it is not possible for the authority to conclude that there are no grounds for applying the tax avoidance clause, and, furthermore, no interpretations appear to be issued regarding elements of the facts or future events which are reasonably foreseeable to be the subject of a decision under the anti-avoidance clause. An application for a protective tax ruling may relate not only to a planned action, but also to actions already initiated or carried out.

In order to avoid any negative consequences or potential disputes with the tax administration, any application should be submitted as early as possible. It is important to note that, despite the requirement to describe in detail all the circumstances of the act to be assessed, the interested party does not have to indicate the tax consequences, including financial benefits, resulting from the act covered by the application. The Supreme Administrative Court has also expressed such a position in one of its judgments.

One should be aware that merely submitting an application for a protective tax ruling does not prevent verification activities, tax inspections, tax proceedings or customs tax inspections being carried out. This instrument is not, however, particularly popular: by the end of 2019, only 9 decisions on protective rulings had been issued, three of which were negative, and the small number of entities which have used this instrument is probably due to the amount of the fee for an application for a protective ruling, which is PLN 20,000. Nevertheless, it is worthwhile considering this method of protection in specific cases.

Marcin Malinowski
Advocate

Jakub Przybyliński
Advocate Trainee

View more resources

Catch up on the very latest B2RLAW
announcements and news here.

21/05/2024

Bogdan Duda at Battery Forum Poland: 22-24 May 2024

Bogdan Duda will represent B2RLaw at Battery Forum Poland: Trade Fair for Batteries and Energy Storage Technologies and Power Supply. […]

MORE
20/05/2024

Panel Discussion: Well-being for Poland: challenges and opportunities

Last week we celebrated #2H4Family #HumanBE impacting work culture and lifestyle. In addition, on 17th May at the invitation of Harvard Club […]

MORE
07/05/2024

Promotions in B2RLaw 2023/2024

May in B2RLaw gives us many reasons to celebrate this year! On the one hand, the return of our brave […]

MORE
04/04/2024

B2RLaw on a New York expedition!

Embarking on an exciting trip to NYC to deepen ties and explore synergies between the US and Poland! B2RLaw will […]

MORE
27/03/2024

B2RLaw recommended in the Legal 500 EMEA ranking 2024

We are proud to announce that in this year’s edition of The Legal 500 we have been recommended in 8 categories […]

MORE
26/03/2024

Andrzej Zając speaks at “Poland’s Energy Evolution: Understanding EU Regulations”

Today Andrzej Zając (Advocate, Partner, Head of Real Estate & Energy) was the speaker at “Poland’s Energy Evolution: Understanding EU Regulations” webinar. Andrzej […]

MORE

Get in touch

Not sure who to contact? Let us help you find the right lawyer.

This site uses cookies to improve your experience More information.

The cookie settings on this website are set to "allow cookies" to give you the best browsing experience possible. If you continue to use this website without changing your cookie settings or you click "Accept" below then you are consenting to this.

Close